Our firm recently assisted the EVGA group of companies, renowned for its gaming graphics cards, in successfully pursuing a counterclaim against a distributor operating in China (the Distributor), securing damages exceeding 80% of the amount claimed in the counterclaim.
The dispute arose from after-sales arrangements relating to transactions between 2019 and 2021. The Distributor commenced proceedings against EVGA, seeking a cash refund of unused credits issued for returned products. Our firm acted for EVGA in defending the proceedings, bringing the Distributor’s claim to a halt.
In parallel, under the computer hardware transactions related to the main claim, the Distributor neither returned certain batches of graphics cards supplied as replacement stock nor accepted EVGA’s proposed alternative of retaining those cards upon payment of their value. Our firm assisted EVGA in pursuing a counterclaim based on detinue and conversion, securing judgment while the Distributor’s main claim went no further. Following an assessment of damages, the Court awarded EVGA damages exceeding 80% of the amount claimed in the counterclaim, together with interest and costs.
The outcome reflects our firm’s longstanding approach to litigation: a good offence is the best defence. Beyond defending claims, we make strategic use of counterclaims and other procedural mechanisms to secure the best possible outcome. We are pleased to have helped EVGA achieve this favourable result.
For more details, please refer to TimesRunner International Co., Ltd v ETI Technology (HK) Limited and EVGA (Hong Kong) Company Limited [2026] HKDC 2093.
Special thanks to Ms Cherry Xu, barrister, for her able support at the assessment of damages hearing. We also thank the collegial team of EVGA, including a former official who flew to Hong Kong to testify in the assessment of damages proceedings.
